Friday, March 29, 2024
  • Revizto - Leaderboard - March and April
  • Keith Walking Floor - Leaderboard - Sept 2021
  • Procore - Leaderboard - Jan 2022
  • Dentec - Leaderboard - 2023 - Updated
  • IAPMO R&T Lab - Leaderboard
  • Premier Leaderboard - updated Nov 19
  • CWRE 2024 - Leaderboard
January 22, 2019

Opinion – Block Royalmount by withholding infrastructure work

 

 

It’s nonsensical that the Town of Mount Royal, with just one per cent of the population on the island of Montreal, can impose the Royalmount project on everyone else, says a leading urban planner.

“I think it’s a question of democracy,” said Raphaël Fischler, dean of urban planning at the Université de Montréal.

In an interview Monday, he said the $2-billion project — expected to worsen traffic on the already congested Décarie Expressway and Highway 40 — should be sent back to the drawing board.

Fischler called on the Quebec government, the city of Montreal and the agglomeration council to halt Royalmount by requiring developer Carbonleo to pay for all infrastructure work necessitated by the project.

“I believe that the developer and T.M.R. can be brought to the table and forced to reconsider the project,” he said.

Fischler made the comments just three days before the agglomeration council’s standing committee on urban and economic development and housing is due to submit its recommendations on the controversial mega-mall.

“It’s the 11th hour,” he acknowledged.

In a written brief to the committee, Fischler said that allowing Royalmount to go ahead would be a mistake akin to the 1973 demolition of the Van Horne mansion in downtown Montreal — an event that launched the city’s heritage movement.

The Royalmount project is “an aberration in the management of Montreal’s development,” he writes in the brief.

It “goes against logic and good practices in the management of urban development” and even democracy that T.M.R., with fewer than 20,000 residents, has the power to approve a project that will have an enormous impact on surrounding municipalities and the highway network, he says.

The mega-mall would have “the intended effect, if not the explicit goal, of weakening existing main streets, shopping centres and theatres so this private project can make money. In a few years, it could undo decades of efforts to inject life into downtown and neighbourhoods” as well as decades of public efforts to have a thriving downtown people can reach without having to drive, the brief says.

On Monday, Fischler said the city and the agglomeration council have abdicated their responsibility to draw up a master plan for development in the area around the Décarie north of Jean-Talon St.

The Royalmount project puts the power of “planning part of the city” in the hands of a single, private developer, he said.

Keep reading in the Montreal Gazette

 


Watch the video and learn more about the benefits of joining Construction Links Network – the peer-to-peer network sharing platform for the construction, building and design community.

Ideal for YOUR Press Releases | Project Updates | New Appointments | Awards & Milestones | Company News | New Products/Services | Brochures | Videos | Infographics | Blog Sharing | Events and More